Fitch: The "Big Four" European reinsurers resist pricing competition

Pricing discipline by Munich Re, Swiss Re, Hannover Re and SCOR is proving an important competitive advantage in the face of declining market pricing and investment yields, Fitch Ratings says in a report published on 16 August.

The recent Fitch's "European Reinsurance Peer Review" report compares and contrasts the key credit factors affecting the ratings of the 4 major European reinsurers. According to its findings, the four largest European reinsurers have been able to largely maintain their pricing and policy terms to protect earnings without a significant fall in business volumes, helped by their strong market positions. They all reported strong property and casualty (P&C) underwriting results in 2016, albeit helped by prior-year reserve releases and lower-than-expected major losses, which cannot be counted on to continue.

Most of their operating profit comes from P&C reinsurance but we expect a growing contribution from life reinsurance, driven partly by life insurers seeking to transfer longevity risk in response to higher regulatory capital requirements from the introduction of Solvency II. SCOR in particular is building its life reinsurance business following two major acquisitions in recent years.

All four companies have maintained very strong capitalisation in recent years, which is important for their ratings. They all score "Very Strong" or "Extremely Strong" in Fitch's Prism factor-based capital model. Their financial leverage ratios (FLRs) are low compared with most primary insurers in Europe and likely to remain so while the competitive market limits opportunities for growth. Munich Re's Fitch-calculated FLR is the lowest of the four: 13% at end-2016, and now materially lower following repayment of EUR1.5 billion of subordinated debt, which reduced the Fitch-calculated FLR by 3.8 percentage points.

Pricing in the wider reinsurance market is under intense pressure following several years of below-average major losses and an influx of capital to the sector as investors look for higher returns than they can get from investment markets. The Fitch-calculated combined ratio, excluding the impact of prior-year reserve releases and lower-than-expected major losses, was nearly 100% in aggregate in 2016 even for the four major European reinsurers, indicating underwriting profit little better than break-even. Our fundamental outlook for the reinsurance sector is negative and we expect profitability to weaken as pricing and investment yields continue to decline.

The latest issue of the Fitch European Reinsurance Peer Review is available here.

In key financial metric terms, the four big reinsurers analyzed by Fitch are holding together an assets volume of almost EUR 590 billion and have written in 2016 premiums worth EUR 114.7 billion.

Fitch Ratings says in its new report that all four of the major European reinsurers reported lower-than-expected large loss experience in 1H17, which helped them to maintain underwriting profitability.  However, on a normalised basis, adjusting for variances from budgeted totals for major losses and prior year reserve development, the combined ratio for both Munich Reinsurance Company (Munich Re) and Hannover Rueck SE (Hannover Re) was above 100% in 1H17, indicating that had major loss experience and reserve development been in line with expectations, these insurers would have made underwriting losses.

Overall, their return on investments continued to decline, with three of the four major European reinsurers reporting a modest decline in investment income. Hannover Re reported higher investment income, despite a lower yielding fixed income portfolio, driven by income from private equity and real estate funds. The short-duration investment portfolios of reinsurers further expose them to the diminishing rate of return upon reinvestment.

The major European reinsurers hold very strong levels of risk-adjusted capital based on both Fitch's Prism Factor Based Model assessment and their regulatory-assessed solvency coverage. All four reported regulatory ratios in excess of the lower end of their target ranges and well in excess of the regulatory minimum.

Munich Re and Swiss Reinsurance Company Limited (Swiss Re) reported a reduction in P&C reinsurance gross premiums written, due to the targeted withdrawal from unprofitable lines of business. Conversely Hannover Re and SCOR SE (SCOR) both reported growth, of 16.9% and 10.6% respectively, at constant exchange rates. Hannover Re reported increased demand for structured reinsurance solutions, which more than offset premium declines in other areas, whereas SCOR benefitted from the impact of large contracts written in the US during 2H16.

Throughout 1H17, portfolio level rate reductions have been smaller than in 2016 for each of the major European reinsurers, but pricing remains under pressure. Record growth of catastrophe bond issuance and collateralised reinsurance is putting a further strain on pricing, especially in relation to US natural catastrophe exposed lines.

Related articles


Bridging the protection gap in Eastern Europe

For some families living in the former industrial regions of Eastern European countries, the social welfare payments offered by the Government are the most expected moment, each and every month. They are most helpful as a survival tool but, at the same time, combined with insufficient or even sometimes inexistent state-driven programs for tackling these issues, are considered by experts as a factor against actual change in both mentalities and lives.


What is happening with the Romanian private pensions' Second Pillar?

The future of the mandatory Second Pillar pensions is among the most disputed subjects, in the last period. After the rumors saying they'll be nationalized, the last discussions show that the participants' contribution will be reduced possibly to 1% from the current 5.1%, which will have a significant impact over the future pensions.


2017 is a revolutionary year for the Russian insurance market

2017 is an anniversary year. A hundred years after a series of key events in the history of our country and in one separate segment of the Russian economy such as insurance there will be also revolutionary events, after which the insurance market, apparently, will never be the same.


Travel Insurance compensation in case of a delay or cancellation? Sense or non-sense?

Whether it's buying the best airline ticket or finding the best travel insurance, people want an easy way to understand and compare products online. But, when it comes to submitting a (flight delay compensation) claim, people will find it difficult, time-consuming and complicated. Would a legally eligible claim need to be covered under a travel insurance policy or would a traveller seek to file a complaint to the airline carrier him-/herself? Would there be a strong support for travellers, who are eligibly entitled to compensation, with customer-friendly travel insurance benefits?


Swiss Re: Disasters resulting in economic losses, almost double the level in 2015

Total economic losses and global insured losses from natural catastrophes and man-made disasters in 2016 were the highest since 2012, reversing the downtrend of the previous four years, Swiss Re sigma says. Globally there were 327 disaster events in 2016, of which 191 were natural catastrophes and 136 were man-made. In total, the disasters resulted in economic losses of USD 175 billion, almost double the level in 2015. 


Global insurance industry: EUR 3.6 trillion in 2016, up 4.4% y-o-y

Initial projections by ALLIANZ Research suggest that total global premium income rose to a new record high of eur 3,650 billion last year (excluding health insurance). In a y-o-y comparison, the nominal increase - after adjustments to reflect foreign currency translation effects - comes to an estimated 4.4%.


Despite its complexities, insurers and companies can get to grips with cyber risk, Swiss Re sigma says

Cyber risk is a growing concern for businesses, with recent attacks demonstrating that the costs of a cyber breach can escalate well beyond managing the fallout of lost or corrupted data. Swiss Re's latest sigma report "Cyber: getting to grips with a complex risk", says businesses need to do much more to integrate cyber security into their risk management programmes. Initiatives to boost cyber resilience are underway.




61st "Rendez-Vous de Septembre" ends today in Monte Carlo: review

The 61st edition of the "Rendez-Vous de Septembre", the annual traditional meeting of reinsurers ends today in Monte Carlo. The Nat Cat insurance protection gap, as well as the global insurance market readiness to deal with the increasing complexity of the cyber risks were among the most debated topics.



MONTE CARLO: Live news from the "Rendez-Vous de Septembre"

The 61st edition of the "Rendez-Vous de Septembre", the annual traditional meeting of reinsurers has started yesterday in Monte Carlo. XPRIMM publications on the CEE, SEE and CIS insurance markets are available at the XPRIMM stand in Fairmont Hotel as well as at the other event's venues.


See all